War Poems Comparison
– The Send-Off And Ducle Et Decorum Est Essay, Research Paper
All Wilfred Owens?s poems seem to rhyme. The ends of the alternate lines rhyme in most all of his poems for example in ?The send off? The 1st line ends in way and the 3rd in gay. This is repeated with other rhyming words all through the poem. On the 7th and 9th lines the rhyme is tramp and camp. In ?Ducle et decorum est? we can see the same format of rhyming. The end of each alternate line rhymes i.e. the ends of the 1st and 3rd lines in this case sacks and backs, and the end of the 9th and 10th lines fumbling and stumbling.
Both these poems were written in the 1st world war and are by the author Wilfred Owen who died seven days before the end of the first world war. Both suggest that the out come of the war was grim for the vast majority of solders who if they came home at all would ether return home dead or injured.
Death seems to be mentioned a lot in Wilfred Owen?s poems for example the title of ?Ducle et decorum est? in an English translation means It is sweet and fitting to die for ones country. Throughout the poem more pictures are painted of death and funerals e.g.
?As under a green sea I saw him drowning.?
?He plunges at me guttering, choking, drowning?
From the next quotes we can see that Wilfred Owen must have suffered from nightmares about the war and the trenches. He says
?In all my dreams before my helpless sight?
?He plunges at me guttering, choking, drowning?
?If in some smothering dreams you too could pace
Behind the wagon that we flung him in?
Pictures of death are also painted in the poem ?The send-off? and I think that Wilfred Owen is trying to put forward the idea that when you are ?sent off? you never come back.
?A few, a few too few for drums and yells,
may creep back silent to village wells?
The quote below shows us that Wilfred Owen saw ?The send-off? as a funeral. The quote leads you to get the impression that death is mocking the flowers and spray and turning them into flowers and spray for funerals.
?Nor there if they yet mock what women meant
Who gave them flowers?
?Shall they return to beating bells?
on line 16 is almost asking a question. Will they return? I think this shows us that Wilfred Owens?s view of war from personal experience tells us that he hated the war and saw it as a grim affair. The next quote tell us that he saw the men as dead as soon as they got on the train.
?Their breasts were stuck all white with wreath and spray
As men?s are dead?
The next quote has an oxymoron in it Grimly gay.
?And lined the train with faces grimly gay?
By doing this Wilfred Owen tells us that the solders that are lining the train are happy but this is shadowed by the fact that they are going to war and may not becoming back this makes the title seem ironic ?The Send-off? I feel that this implying that they may not come back and they have been sent off into the unknown.
?We never heard to which front these were sent.?
In Dulce et decorum est Owen tries to paint a very vivid picture of what life in the trenches was like he describes the men as ?Old beggars? and tells us that they were ?coughing like hags? He also uses the word trudge in line 5 and this tells us that the men are slowly moving towards their destination and are not physically or mentally fit but are slowly lifting one foot after the other and placing it down into the ?sludge? (mentioned in line 2). They seem to have known energy left at all. He mentions that the men ?marched asleep? and this gives you an idea that they had not slept for few days and what sleep they did get was not worth mentioning. So I won?t. The men had quite clearly been injured or had lost their equipment he says
?Many had lost their boots
But limped on blood-shod?
He tells us that the men were ?Drunk with fatigue? and were deaf even
?to the hoots
of gas shells dropping softly behind?
This enforces the picture that Owen has so vividly painted of the men. Coughing, ill with no equipment trudging through the sludge of no mans land.
Wilfred Owens experience of war seems to be portrayed in both Dulce et decorum Est and The send off. In Line 2 of Dulce et decorum Est Owen mentions ?we? and I feel that this implies that he is writing from personal experience and not from something that he has seen while he was in the trenches. This is both his view and the view of his men as he says ?we?.
?Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through the sludge?
Both these poems leave the reader with a melancholy thought in the send off Wilfred Owen describes the solders coming home to a village they do not know and in dulce et decorum est he says that dulce et decorum est is a lie and that we shouldn?t tell our children that its sweet and fitting to die for ones country. I like the way the last line is short in both poems it gives the poem more of an impact.
I think that Wilfred Owen is trying to bring the horrors of war to the reader in the last verse of each poem. In dulce et decorum est he asks the reader if they could follow the wagon with the injured solider in and in the send off he relates the solders return to the village and asks how many are going to come home.