Eugene Victor Debs Essay, Research Paper
*************************************************** THIS THESIS PAPER IS THE ORIGINAL WORK OF THE *
* AUTHOR. IT MAY ONLY BE USED AS AN AID TO *
* RESEARCH OR IN A BIBLIOGRAPHY. IT TOOK ME A *
* GREAT DEAL OF TIME TO WRITE THIS, AND IT IS *
* JUST PLAIN WRONG TO PLAGIARIZE IT. REGARDS, *
* MATTHEW BURKETT (AUTHOR)…………………..*
EUGENE VICTOR DEBS
MATTHEW S. BURKETT
Thesis: Through his writings, speaking tours, and five presidential campaigns as the Socialist Party of America?s candidate, Eugene Victor Debs won the respect of American unionists, radicals, and even those who did not accept his economic doctrines.
I. Background Information
D. Influence in early life
A. Secretary-treasurer of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen
B. Indiana State Legislature
C. President of the American Railway Union
D. Leader of the Pullman Workers
E. Socialist Party of America
III. Post Prison
1. Government by Injunction
2. Industrial Unionism (1911)
3. Walls and Bars (1927)
4. Canton, Ohio
B. Appeal to Reason
1. Socialist publications
2. Presidential candidates
IV. New Ideas
A. “ARU” converts to Social Democratic Party of America
B. Socialist Party of America
C. Populist Party
Through his writings, speaking tours, and five presidential campaigns as the Socialist Party of America?s candidate, Eugene Debs won the respect of American unionists, radicals, and even those who did not accept his economic doctrines.
Eugene Victor Debs was born on November 5, 1855, in Terre Haute, Indiana, where his French immigrant parents, after considerable hardship, had settled. Debs began work in the town?s railroad shops at the age of 15, soon becoming a locomotive fireman. Thrown out of work by the Depression of the 1870s, he left Terre Haute briefly to find a railroad job but soon returned to work as a clerk in a wholesale grocery company. Even though he was no longer a fireman, he joined the “Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen” (BLF) in 1874 and rose rapidly in the union. In 1878 he became an associate editor of the Firemen?s Magazine. Two years later he was appointed editor of the magazine and secretary-treasurer of the brotherhood.
Debs also pursued a political career in the early 1880s. A popular and earnest young man, he was elected city clerk of Terre Haute as a Democrat in 1879 and reelected in 1881. Soon after his second term ended in January 1884, he
was elected to the Indiana Legislature, serving one term [H. W. Wilson Company, pp. 218-219].
During the 1880s Debs remained a craft unionist, devoted to “orthodox” ideals of work, thrift, and respectable unionism [Johnson, p. 183]. With the Firemen?s Brotherhood as his base, he sought to develop cooperation among the
various railroad brotherhoods. A weak federation was achieved in 1889, but it soon collapsed due to internal rivalries [H. W. Wilson Company, p.219]. Tired and discouraged, Debs resigned his positions in the Firemen?s Brotherhood in 1892, only to be reelected over his protest [H. W. Wilson Company, p. 219].
Debs? new project was an industrial union, one which would unite all railroad men, whatever their specific craft, in one union. By mid-1893, the American Railway Union (ARU) was established, with Debs as its first president [Selvin, p. 63]. Labor discontent and the severe national depression beginning in 1893 swelled the union?s ranks. The ARU won a major strike against the Great Northern Railroad early in the spring of 1894 [Johnson, p. 183]. Nevertheless, when the Pullman Company Works near Chicago were struck in May, Debs was reluctant to endorse a sympathetic strike of all railroad men. His union took a
militant stance, however, refusing to move Pullman railroad cars nationally. By July, Debs felt the boycott was succeeding, but a sweeping legal injunction against the union leadership and the use of Federal troops broke the strike. Debs was sentenced to six months in jail for contempt of court, and his lawyer, Clarence Darrow, appealed unsuccessfully to the U.S. Supreme Court [Ginger, p. 164].
Having moved from craft to industrial unionism, Debs now converted to socialism. Convinced that capitalism and competition inevitably led to class strife, Debs argued that the profit system should be replaced by a cooperative commonwealth. “I am opposed to the form of our present government; and I am opposed to the social system in which we live [Representative American Speeches, p. 183].” In essence, Debs felt that the economic theory and practice of capitalism put an excessive amount of stress on the relationship between the
worker and the state. Socialism improves upon this relationship. Although he advocated radical change, he rejected revolutionary violence and chose to bring his case to the public through political means. He participated in the establishment of the Social Democratic party in 1898 and its successor, the Socialist Party of America, in 1901 [Selvin, p. 155].
Debs was the Socialist candidate for president five times. His role was that of a spokesman for radical reform rather than that of a party theorist. Debs conveyed to the public the ideas of the party theorist, Karl Marx. A unifying agent, he tried to remain aloof from the persistent factional struggle between the
evolutionary Socialists and the party?s more revolutionary western wing. The emerging American Socialist movement endorsed a peaceful and evolutionary change. In contrast, the Russian Socialist movement favored revolutionary
“Are we opposed to Prussian militarism? [Laughter.] [Shouts from the crowd of "Yes. Yes."] Why, we have been fighting it since the day the Socialist movement was born; [applause]
and we are going to continue to fight it, day and night, until it is wiped from the face of the earth. [Thunderous applause and cheers.] Between us there is no truce – no compromise
[Schlesinger, pp. 417-433, stanza 14].”
As the party?s presidential candidate in 1900 and 1904, he led the Socialists to a fourfold increase in national voting strength, from about 97,000 to more than 400,000 votes [Johnson, p. 183]. While the party?s vote did not increase significantly in 1908, Debs drew attention to the Socialist case by a
dramatic national tour in the “Red Special”, a campaign train [Ginger, pp. 268-284]. The year 1912 proved to be the high point for Debs and his party. He won 897,011 votes, 6 percent of the total [Johnson, p. 184].
When World War I began in 1914, the party met with hard times. The Socialists were the only party to oppose economic assistance to the allies and the preparedness movement. The United States government?s policy stated that military preparedness for entrance into the war was necessary. Debs, while refusing the Socialist nomination for president in 1916, endorsed the party view that President Woodrow Wilson?s neutrality policies would lead to war. In 1917
America?s entrance into war resulted in widespread antagonism toward the Socialists [H. W. Wilson Company, p. 220]. When Debs spoke out in 1918 against the war and Federal harassment of Socialists, he was arrested and convicted of sedition under the wartime Espionage Act [Ginger, p. 359-379]. During wartime, rejection of the governmental policies of the United States is
considered both sedition and a compromise of national security. “In prison he became his party?s martyred hero, ?Saint Gene,? some comrades called him [Woodward, p.42]. He ran for the last time as the Socialist presidential candidate while in prison, receiving nearly a million votes, more actual votes (but a smaller
percentage of the total) than in 1912 [Johnson, p. 221].
On Christmas Day 1921, President Warren G. Harding pardoned Debs, but Debs could do little to restore life to the Socialist party, battered by the war years and split over the Russian Revolution [Ginger, pp. 437-454]. Debs had welcomed the Revolution; yet he became very critical of the dictatorial aspects of the Soviet
regime, refusing to ally himself with the American Communist Party [Ginger, pp. 397-398; pp. 431-456]. Debs died on October 20, 1926, having won wide respect as a resourceful evangelist for a more humane, cooperative society. “And a million workingmen will answer with their cheers and pledge their faith with their votes [Debs, Eugene V. and Bruce Rogers, pp. 499-509, stanza 21]!”
Debs, Eugene V. and Bruce Rogers. Debs: His Life, Writings, and Speeches. Girard, Kansas: The Appeal to Reason, 1908. (pp. 499-509).
Ginger, Ray. The Bending Cross: A Biography of Eugene Victor Debs. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1948.
H.W. Wilson Company. American Reformers: An H.W. Wilson Biographical Dictionary. New York: The H.W. Wilson Company, 1985. (pp. 218-221).
Johnson, Allen. Dictionary of American Biographies. New York: Charles Scribriner?s Sons, 1952. (pp. 183-185).
Representative American Speeches. New York: New Horizons, 1978. (pp. 183-185).
Schlesinger, Arthur M. Writings and Speeches of Eugene V. Debs. New York: Heritage Press, 1948. (pp. 417-433).
Selvin, David F. Eugene Debs, Rebel, Labor Leader, Prophet. New York: Lothrop, Lee, and Sherard, Co., Inc., 1966.
Spargo, June. Incarnate Spirit of Revolt: Speeches by Eugene V. Debs. New York: Heritage Press, 1908.
Woodward, C. Vann. Homegrown Radical: Letters of Eugene V. Debs, 1874-1926. Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 1991. (pp. 40-42).