, Research Paper
Comparison of 1984 and Animal Farm
In George Orwell’s 1984 and Animal Farm, reality is defined by what
the leaders tell the commoners it is, and the idea of individuality and free
thought are abolished in order to preserve that reality. 1984 demonstrated the
concept of a perceived reality versus a true reality, and Animal Farm revealed
that reality is in the beholder.
The Outer Party members in 1984 were oblivious to the true reality of
their lives and blindly accepted whatever was told to them. An excellent
example of the Outer Party’s ignorance to truth is when they are told that their
chocolate rations have been increased, when actually the rations were just
reduced a week earlier. Because of the Party’s successful assault on the
individuality of its members, people became cheerful when they heard of the news.
This perceived reality is the truth to the Party members.
The true reality in 1984 is shown only to the reader and some Inner
Party members. O’Brien knows the real truth of things as shown by his torturing
of Winston. He tells Winston that if the Party tells the people that 2+2=5,
then it does. He also instructs Winston that if the Party informs its members
that 2+2=3 or 4 or all at the same time, then it is so. Although this true
reality is available to Inner Party members, they too do not have the freedom of
thought or individuality… they are only just aware of its existence. Only the
outside reader is able to think and understand the true nature of the reality
established by the Party.
In Animal Farm, Orwell unveiled that reality is a simple mental state
that can be easily manipulated. Napoleon and the pigs proved this theory by
repeatedly changing the Seven Commandments and reporting to the other animals
that the ‘laws’ had always been in their changed condition when they were
questioned. Napoleon uses the terror wielded by the dogs to rule the farm with
an iron fist, and none of the animals realize it, none that is, except Benjamin.
The pigs are able to defeat free thinking and retain ultimate supremacy by
controlling the minds of the other animals, and by controlling the minds of the
commoners, both Napoleon and the Party demonstrated that reality can be changed
and manipulated to abolish individuality and ‘force’ the people to see the
reality that is placed before them.